Sunday, September 12, 2010

I’ll have the Wahhhmburger and French Cries

“Have you ever walked down the street and seen a person who you just couldn’t stop staring at? Not because that person was hot or handsome, but because he or she was different and didn’t fit in – didn’t really look like other people.

Well, I’m one of those people. “


None of you have probably heard of Michael Mantell, or have read his self deprecating news article titled “A simple hello might make someone’s day.” I was expecting this article to be about reaching out to others, but rather, it is a whine for attention towards one’s condition.

I personally have never seen someone I could not stop staring at because I was stuck on the thought that that person did not fit in or “didn’t really look like other people.” Either way, we’re all “one of those people.” No two snowflakes are alike. At this day and age we have all learned that we are all different.

In a nutshell, Michael stands at 4’6”, weighs 120 pounds, and has Systemic Rheumatoud Arthritis. The side effects of his Arthritis have made him overweight. Thus, he sits alone in the cafeteria, and because his disease makes him unattractive and unapproachable, nobody is sitting with him, and he lacks the courage to ask someone to eat with him. Also because of his disease, he does not have someone to eat lunch with, a girlfriend, nor the potential to be the attractive boyfriend that every girl, deep down, wants. His solution to his problem is for us, the cafeteria eating people of Chapman, to make the first move.

Diseases should never be the blame for companionship or friendship. Think of Gabriel Iglesias. Engaged and not fat, but “Fluffy,” he has made not only friends but a career as a comedian out of his obesity and life experiences. Ralphie May, known in the comedy realm as well, previously weighed 800 pounds before turning thirty years old.

Relationship wise, there have always been those weird couples. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The Maury Show recently and currently airs episodes of “odd couples.” I have seen men that were tattooed from head to toe with uninked women and short men with amazons. There have been men in their eighties with women in there twenties.

I’m not saying that this kid is lame for whining about his problems. It’s rather that rather than changing himself, as in being more outgoing, or asking people to eat lunch with him, he wants us as readers to change. They say the key to change is to let go of fear. Frankenstein’s creation went through this trying to fit in with the townspeople of Geneva. Griffin went through the same issues when he became The Invisible Man and is accused of robberies and chased out of the town of Iping.


We don’t know how social Michael attempted to be. We don’t know if he went to Playfair his freshman year, where you make friends for life. We don’t know if during his sophomore year he had trouble making friends, or even if the people at Panther Online even bother to talk to him. But right now, he has 500 friends on Facebook, and is single.

6 comments:

  1. I feel like this tone is honest, blunt, and truthful. I agree with your opinion, and he shouldn't expect others to change. He needs to become more outgoing, and then he'll realize that not everyone is as intimidating as he thinks they are.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I do feel for the guy, but I am going to have to agree with you: he can't just assume and encourage for people to change just for him. Like you said, everyone at college goes through the same getting-to-know- people phase. We all have to gain the courage to talk to different people. I am thinking that this post also has a truthful, honest tone.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have trouble distinguishing if this response is inconsiderate or honest because I feel extremely bad for this guy and I don't really agree with your response. Although this response is extremely well written and you take a stance that otherwise would be hard to take. But my feelings remain unchanged it is extremely hard to get courage and go up to talk to some one if you have never thought you had a reason to be courageous.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You really establish your cynicism toward this person by characterizing his article as a "whine."

    I think you spend too much time summarizing the information about this guy. That's what a hyperlink is for -- if people want to know that, they can follow the link and discover it. You should get right to making points.

    The relationship-wise paragraph needs to flow better -- right now the rhythms are hurky-jerky, each sentence butting up against each other.

    The allusions are plentiful and insightful. Good naming of literature and other obese individuals.

    Great last line. It really captures the pathos of his situation.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As far as the class comments, perhaps because of the voice the author took a stance she would not take otherwise.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My tone was supposed to be funny, but I think it ended up being more snarky and like what AJ said, inconsiderate.

    ReplyDelete